O Little Town of Bethlehem

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure page for more details.

Last Updated on: 5th August 2021, 11:10 am

Listen to the Episode “O Little Town of Bethlehem”

Listen and Subscribe in iTunes

Other ways to Listen and Subscribe

Bethlehem may be the most famous small town on Earth. The town is of course known as the birthplace of Jesus Christ, but beyond its most famous citizen, what do people really know about the city? For me, the answer as “not much.” I had the chance to travel to Bethlehem in March, and I learned so much about the city’s history beyond its Biblical history. My guest today is the man who literally wrote the book on Bethlehem, Nicholas Blincoe. Nicholas wrote the critically hailed Bethlehem: Biography of a Town, and on this episode, we discuss what life was like there in the first century A.D., how that history relates to what’s told in the Bible, and how the legacy of its most famous son affected the town centuries after his birth.

[bctt tweet=”On this week’s episode, @NicholasBlincoe and I talk #Bethlehem’s history. #HIstoryFangirl” via=”no”]




How old is Bethlehem?

Bethlehem is a very old town in a very old region, at the crossroads of two ancient trails: What today is called Hevron Road that runs up to Jerusalem, and then an east-west trail that came from the Dead Sea. And as the aquifer in the area began to be used as a water source for Jerusalem, Bethlehem town grew up to protect the water source, and eventually became a market town for the people who lived there. But as Nicholas says, his “big argument” in the book is that Bethlehem is not as old as the Bible says it is. I won’t spoil the argument here, but you’ll want to hear what he has to say about it.

[bctt tweet=”How old is the city of #Bethlehem, and is it as old as the Bible says? We talk about the city’s earliest days with @NicholasBlincoe. #HIstoryFangirl” username=””]

See also
The West Bank Separation Wall



Bethlehem in Jesus’s Time

I asked Nicholas about the historical evidence of Jesus’s birth in Bethlehem, and he said that while much of the evidence, including the Gospels, is 200 or so years after he would have been born, there are other ways of thinking about it. For instance, while much of it may be a few hundred years after the fact, much of it is built on 200 years of pilgrimage, which is strong evidence for the town as Jesus’s birthplace. And there was an inn on the edge of town where travelers visiting the site of Jesus’ birth would stay. And so Nicholas notes that even though there is no hard evidence, the fact is that people who lived in the time of Christ certainly believed it, making it interesting evidence for a historian.

[bctt tweet=”What was the city of #Bethlehem like in Jesus’s time? Listen to this episode to find out. #HistoryFangirl” username=””]



St. Helena and the Church of the Nativity

Nicholas tells a great story in this episode about St. Helena, who met her husband as a barmaid and would eventually become the mother of the great emperor Constantine. She then ruled over the empire as matriarch, and went on to build what Nicholas calls one of the most unusual churches in the world, the Church of the Nativity. She actually opened up the top of a cave thought to be where Christ was born, and built a rotunda, so you could look down into the place where Jesus was born. As Nicholas says, it makes the church very influential and, perhaps, interesting from a Freudian perspective.

[bctt tweet=”Why does author @NicholasBlincoe describe the Church of the Nativity as a “bit Freudian?” Find out on this week’s #HistoryFangirl” username=””]




What to see in Bethlehem, and how to see it

I asked Nicholas for advice for visiting Bethlehem, and straight away he noted that the typical tour bus is operated by Israelis, and the Palestinian gift shop owners pay those companies to take tourists by their shops. So, as he said, you could feel a little “icky” arranging a trip in that manner. (Though we both make a few recommendations for tours that are on the up-and-up.) He also recommends the Church of the Nativity, of course, and walking Start Street, which was the old pilgrimage route. He also has some really cool suggestions for Roman ruins, holy sites and good places to stop and eat. If you’re thinking of visiting the most famous small town in the world, first listen to this episode, then pick up Nicholas’s book, and then make your plans.

See also
9 of Israel’s Most Ancient Historic Sites for Your Israel Bucket List

To fly into Israel or Palestine, you will need to fly into the town of Tel Aviv. If you choose to stay and explore Tel Aviv, check out this things to do in Tel Aviv..

[bctt tweet=”It’s Christmastime, and you may be thinking about #Bethlehem. Check out this week’s episode about the city’s early days. #HistoryFangirl” via=”no”]



Outline of This Episode

  • [2:26] How Nicholas got interested in Bethlehem
  • [3:48] The origins of Bethlehem
  • [10:18] Bethlehem and King David
  • [14:02] Nabataeans in Bethlehem
  • [19:15] Jesus in Bethlehem
  • [25:52] Is there an argument against Christ being born in Bethlehem?
  • [28:08] The Church of Nativity and St. Helena
  • [38:28] Visiting the church
  • [45:05] Must-sees in Bethlehem



Resources & People Mentioned



Connect With Stephanie

Featuring the song “Places Unseen” by Lee Rosevere.

Leave a Comment